Menu & Prices — Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes

-Italian Style-

-Cheesecake Flavors-

* We now have over 100 different flavors; our most popular are listed below. Our retail store will feature a different variety of flavors and sizes weekly. If you are looking for a specific flavor, we suggest ordering in advance.

Plain

Simple as it gets! A recipe handed down for generations. Ricotta keeps it light and fluffy, with hints of citrus and honey. Try it 'Mom's' way with fudge and canned cherry toppings.

Rainbow Cookies ★

Our best seller! A Guilty Pleasures exclusive, this cheesecake is flooded with pieces of rainbow cookies and topped with raspberry sauce and thick chocolate ganache. Out of this world!

Apple Cinnamon

A little taste of America! This cozy cake is mixed with apples, apple liqueur, brown sugar, and nutmeg. It can also be made with a crumb topping.

Bananas Foster

The popular dessert turned into a mouth-watering cheesecake! Fresh banana puree is mixed into the batter along with rum, brown sugar, and cinnamon. Topped with caramelized bananas and brûléed to perfection.

Blueberry Almond Crunch ★

A delicious mix of flavors! Sweet and crunchy, this cheesecake has a center of real blueberries and almond extract, and is topped with an almond crumb and sprinkled with powdered sugar.

Brownie Explosion

The ultimate chocolate experience! This cheesecake has a yummy brownie base, cheesecake center, and is topped with a delectable chocolate mousse. All covered with chocolate ganache. Insane!

Chocolate Raspberry ★

Raspberries, raspberries, and more raspberries! Raspberry cheesecake with a raspberry and fudge bottom. This delicious creation is topped with raspberry preserves and chocolate ganache.

Coffee with Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

What a rush! Chocolate covered espresso beans mixed into a coffee cheesecake. Covered in chocolate ganache and more chocolate-covered espresso beans. Perfect for an all-nighter!

Chocolate Covered Strawberry or Cherry ★

A classic! Chocolate or Plain cheesecake mixed with your choice of strawberries or cherries with Polish Cherry Liquor. Topped with homemade chocolate-covered strawberries or cherries.

The Elvis

This hunka hunka cheesecake would make the King proud! A peanut butter cheesecake is topped with bananas and honey. Add bacon if you're brave enough. Trust us, it rocks!

Gianduja ★

An Italian favorite! Cheesecake batter is mixed with Nutella to create a rich chocolate hazelnut flavor with pieces of Rocher chocolate mixed in. Topped with chocolate ganache and sprinkled with cocoa powder.

Going Coconuts

Inspired by the candy bar! Shredded coconut and coconut extract are swirled into this decadent cheesecake. Smothered in chocolate ganache and almonds, oh the joy!

Key Lime & White Chocolate Chips

Cheesecake mixed with the juice and zest of key limes and delicious white chocolate chips. The cake is topped with whipped cream.

Lemon Poppy Seed

Inspired by my favorite muffin! This lemon cheesecake is flooded with poppy seeds and topped with whipped cream. Best with a lemon cookie crust and chunks of lemon cookies inside. Yum!

Mango

An unusual flavor with a tropical flair! Mango cheesecake mixed with big chunks of fresh mango and finished with a coconut cookie crust. A must try!

Macaroon

With a macaroon crust, this cheesecake is swirled with fresh macaroons and coconut extract. Try it chocolate-covered for a classic twist...

Pumpkin

A Thanksgiving delight! This pumpkin cheesecake is made with pumpkin puree, nutmeg, vanilla, and cinnamon. It can be filled with caramel, nuts, or made with a crumb topping.

Reese's Peanut Butter Cup

The guiltiest of them all! This peanut butter cheesecake is bombarded with chunks of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, chocolate syrup, and chopped peanuts. Wow!

Salted Caramel ★

A thick layer of caramel lines the crust of this Biscoff cookie flavored cheesecake. It is then covered in more salted caramel and a pretzel peanut toffee crunch! Doesn’t disappoint!

S'mores

With a thick graham cracker crust, our campfire creation is filled with pieces of graham cracker and chocolate chunks. Covered in marshmallows, and more chocolate chunks it is then torched to create that campfire taste. Relax & unwind!

Strawberry Shortcake ★

This cake brings back childhood memories! Layered with angel food cake, fresh strawberries, and strawberry preserves. Topped with whipped cream!

Tiramisu ★

Cinnamon cheesecake with coffee dipped ladyfingers! Topped with whipped cream, and cocoa powder! Timeless!

White Chocolate Macadamia ★

White chocolate cheesecake with big chunks of macadamia nuts throughout. Topped with whipped cream and a pile of chopped macadamia nuts.

Savory Cakes

Buffalo Chicken ★

Spicey, tangy goodness. Made with a buttery cracker crust, buffalo chicken is mixed into this savory batter with hot pepper sauce, mozzarella, and chunks of blue cheese. Add some ranch to cool it down?

Cheeseburger ★

My personal favorite! A potato chip crust holds a batter mixed with caramelized onion, ground beef, A-1, cheddar cheese, and dill pickles! Top with tomatoes and bacon! Classic burger and fries flavor! Heavenly!

Jalapeno Popper ★

Add a little more spice to your day! Your crust is made of a classic cheese cracker, then topped with a little crumbled chorizo. Mixed with cheddar, mozzarella, and jalapeno pieces, this is a real crowd-pleaser.

DOWNLOAD PDF MENU

Pricing-does not include sales tax

Prices Vary for Savory & Custom Cakes

Truffles $27/dozen

Similar to a cake pop, minus the stick. Your cheesecake flavor is mixed with cake, rolled into a ball, and dunked into chocolate. Some of these truffles are even filled with jelly, cherries, or chocolate. Very fancy!

Bite Sized

Plain: $24.00/Dozen

Flavored: $25.50/Dozen

These tiny treasures are more along the line of mini muffins and are the perfect addition to your dessert table!

Yum!

Sampler Box $34.00

*(additional charge for savory)

(4) 4-inch mini cheesecakes

Choose what you want to try! The perfect way to figure out your favorite flavor!

7 inch

plain $25.00

flavored $33.00

specialty flavors (★) $38.00

Savory $42.00

10 inch

plain $35.00

flavored $43.00

specialty flavors (★) $48.00

Savory $52.00

Want to place an order?

(3 days advanced notice required)